I’ve been thinking about stories.

There’s a lot of memoir talk flying around right now. Is writing memoir “cheating”? Are memoirs lazy and narcissistic and opportunistic? Are they inherently dishonest due to their reliance on the flawed mechanism of memory? Why do memoirs now seem intentionally deceitful in greater numbers than ever before?

I found Daniel Mendelsohn’s “But Enough About Me” in The New Yorker to be insightful and educational. I found Taylor Antrim’s “Why Some Memoirs are Better as Fiction” in The Daily Beast to be fairly infuriating. And don’t even get me started on his hairdo in his author photo.

I’m not going to bother defending the genre of memoir here because my friend Stephen Elliott at The Rumpus does so with great eloquence in his response to Antrim, “Defending Memoir, or, The Problem with Taylor.” But I do want to try to field some of the thoughts that have been zinging around in my head and keeping me awake nights, as I prepare for the release of my own memoir while reflecting on the deaths this week of Howard Zinn and J.D. Salinger.

Both Zinn and Salinger had a profound effect on my life at different times, for different reasons. Like about twenty zillion other people, reading Salinger in high school made me feel less alone. Even if I felt dropped from an alien vessel into the lap of my family, there was a family to which I metaphysically belonged- the Glass family. Literature gave me a sense of connectedness, and my relationship with Salinger’s work typified this connection. Nine Stories made me want to write; it lit that little fire in me. Salinger emboldened me to enter my own words into the big dialogue that is writing, that is reading.

And Zinn bolsters me even now when I start to wilt. When I think- who gives a shit about my little story? Who am I to blather on with this self-involved mediocrity? Zinn tells me that that my voice is significant. That my struggle is relevant. That my story is the stuff of history.

And so is yours. So the next time you see me, tell me a story. Maybe it'll be a story that changes the world.

Views: 9

Tags: Antrim, Beast, D., Daily, Daniel, Elliott, Howard, J, Jillian, Lauren, More…Mendelsohn, New, Rumpus, Salinger, Stephen, Taylor, The, Yorker, Zinn

Comment

You need to be a member of She Writes to add comments!

Join She Writes

Comment by Yolanda Navarra Fleming on February 20, 2010 at 7:54am
I forogt to mention, I'm also from New Jersey. Just read that on your site. What suburb? I'm in Rumson (Jersey Shore).
Comment by Yolanda Navarra Fleming on February 20, 2010 at 7:49am
You just became my new hero(ine), Jillian. "Who gives a shit about my little story?" I've been saying that to myself for years, which is why it's taken this long (14 years) to finish my thesis on self-involved mediocrity. When I get down about it, I remind myself the fact that I read one memoir after another and absolutely prefer them to any fiction out there. I want to read what's real. I want to learn what pushes other people from one day to the next without offing themselves. Life is hard, but for me, reading memoirs makes me feel less alone. Just knowing that someone else is self-analyzing and willing to share it with the world, makes me sure I would be foolish not to. True, my story is far less interesting from a subject standpoint than yours, which I am excited to read, but it doesn't mean it's any less relevant. Perhaps someone will read my book and identify with it more than they identify with yours because it's a more common story. It's so common, in fact, that I am having a very hard time writing a synopsis. Just thinking about it gives me the shakes. But my message is a very important one and I have a feeling it's similar to your message, which is no more complicated than this: Think twice, girls, before getting involved with someone. Value yourself more. Listen to your gut instincts and believe in yourself.

Thanks, in advance, for have the guts to share your story. Opportunistic? Maybe. But any writer or writing teacher I've ever come across has said, "Write what you know." So there.

Have a fabulous weekend. Would love to hear from you.

Latest Activity

A blog post by Alissa Johnson was featured

The Mindsets that Keep You From Starting (and Finishing) Your Book: Part II

Last week we talked about the "I Don't Knows"—how the weight of everything you think you need…See More
18 minutes ago
Catherine Stine commented on the group 'Social Networking'
"Launch day!DORIANNA, a dark YA twist on Dorian Gray is OUT! Do you like psychological horror? Ever been totally charmed by a nefarious guy? Do you get a kick out of toxic love…"
27 minutes ago
Catherine Stine commented on the group 'Speculative Fiction Writers'
"Launch day!DORIANNA, a dark YA twist on Dorian Gray is OUT! Do you like psychological horror? Ever been totally charmed by a nefarious guy? Do you get a kick out of toxic love…"
29 minutes ago
Catherine Stine commented on the group 'Writers for Young Adults'
"DORIANNA, a dark YA twist on Dorian Gray is OUT! Do you like psychological horror? Ever been totally charmed by a nefarious guy? Do you get a kick out of toxic love…"
30 minutes ago

Members

Badge

Loading…

© 2014   Created by Kamy Wicoff.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service