What Would Diane Lockhart Do? And Why It Matters to Writers

Last week I had a few bad days. A conflict at work was niggling at me. Things weren’t going well with an editor. Work on my latest book was dragging. The stress turned into a giant migraine, making me cancel my classes for a day—something I detest doing.

I spent Thursday nursing my headache and feeling sorry for myself, saying dumb things like, Why is everything going wrong? Then I asked myself a question: Under these circumstances, what would Diane Lockhart do?

For those of you unfamiliar with the TV series The Good Wife, Diane Lockhart is the fictional head of a law firm. Developed by writers Michelle and Robert KingLeonard Dick, and Dee Johnson, and expertly played by the amazing Christine Baranski, Lockhart is the most dimensional, interesting, and commanding female figure on TV.

Diane Lockhart is not one of the pretty 20-somethings that animate America’s TV screens each night. She is not the young mother of a goofy family, or the girlfriend of a male lead. She is an older woman—Baranski is 62—yet she is not relegated to the role of irritating mother-in-law, cookie-baking grandma, or nosy neighbor lady. Unlike many older women on TV, she is not sexless, eccentric, or evil and, with her stunning wardrobe and impeccable taste, she is the diametric opposite of dowdy. She got married at some point in the series, but that was a minor plot line, and her husband has neither been seen on screen nor referred to for many episodes.

Most importantly, Diane Lockhart is powerful. Her power derives from intelligence, wisdom, experience, and confidence. She wants what is good for herself and good for her firm. She knows what is fair. She works from her strengths. She is neither bullying nor conniving, but she knows how to set up a good quid pro quo and can throw a mean metaphorical punch.

When I climbed out of bed on Thursday afternoon, took a couple ibuprofen, and asked myself WWDLD, I meant it. That poised, self-assured fictional woman wouldn’t be lying around grumbling. She would figure out her next step in the wink of an eye, and take action. If she could do that, so could I.

In this story lurks a lesson for writers. Because if you’re writing well, you can create characters that actually affect people’s lives. Good characters have strengths, flaws, bad habits, good habits, peccadillos and quirks. They seem so familiar and real that we feel their joy, fear, laughter and pain, and even grieve when they die (as many did when another Good Wife character was recently killed).

We learn from characters. We are inspired by their strengths and appalled by their mistakes. We recognize our own flaws and assets in theirs. We see their missteps and grow as they do. They can show us new ways of being in the world.

I’m not saying you should set out to create characters that will help people through hard times or teach life lessons. That's the last thing you should do. What you should set out to do is create characters with all the complexities and contradictions of real people. If you do it well, and your characters come to life on the page—or the TV screen—there’s no telling how they will affect your reader. Keep that awareness constantly in the back of your mind as you write. Devote yourself to imagining intricate, multifaceted, believable people. Then leave it up to your readers to find in that depth and complexity exactly what they need.

Views: 130


You need to be a member of She Writes to add comments!

Join She Writes

Comment by Jill Jepson on April 23, 2014 at 12:26pm

Patricia: Yes! You've nailed it better than I did. Martinis first. Something outrageously perfect second! 

Comment by Patricia Robertson on April 23, 2014 at 12:12pm

I'm thinking she would throw down a few martinis first and then come up with something strong, almost outrageous! :)

Comment by Jill Jepson on April 23, 2014 at 8:38am

Hi Patricia. She'd do exactly what I say: "She would figure out her next step in the wink of an eye, and take action." That next step would be be based on identifying her strengths and how she can apply them. So, that's what I'm working on now for myself!

Comment by Jill Jepson on April 23, 2014 at 8:35am

Thanks for your comment, Carol. If you start it, start from the beginning. It starts great and gets better.

Comment by Carol Apple on April 23, 2014 at 7:27am

Oh my gosh - what have I been missing? My husband and I have watched all the available episodes of "House of Cards" and have been looking around for our next series. I think I have found it! This Diane Lockhard sounds like a really interesting character. I use literary characters all the time to help me deal with situations and also to understand other people.

Comment by Patricia Robertson on April 23, 2014 at 6:44am

So what would Diane Lockhart do in your situation?????

Comment by Jill Jepson on April 22, 2014 at 3:47pm

Thanks, Mardith. I'm glad you enjoyed the post!

Comment by Mardith Louisell on April 22, 2014 at 1:17pm

Terrific reminder, Jill.  I haven't watched Good Wife for years but loved Christine and think she is, as you say, a woman to consider in the all too frequent moment of immobilized self-pity. Thanks for the post.


Latest Activity

Paula M. Friedman posted blog posts
2 hours ago
Amanda Wilson liked Isabel Farhi's page Community
2 hours ago
Sonja Benskin Mesher posted blog posts
3 hours ago
Pamela Kivi posted a blog post

Feeding the Writer with a Day Trip

Northfield is my favorite town to take a day trip in the warm seasons. It is an rich autumn trip to drive by the apple orchards and farmhouses. The town is just far enough from the Cities that it feels like you left on a vacation. You have to pass…See More
4 hours ago




© 2017   Created by Kamy Wicoff.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service