When my memoir How to Sleep Alone in a King-Size Bed came out, people would sometimes say to me, “Writing this must have been very therapeutic for you.” And I would, I have to admit, cringe.
Why the cringe? I cringed because I see the book as a story that I had worked long hours to craft and shape. I see writing as something I love, but it's also my job. When I think of "therapeutic writing," I picture long scrawled journal pages of unfiltered, uncensored feelings. When the word therapeutic is used in reference to my work, I feel a smidge patronized. Why don't you just pat me on the head while you’re at it?
However, there are a couple of problems with this objection. One: I sound like an ingrate. These people are most often readers of my book–maybe even buyers of my book. They are mostly likely well intended and simply wanting to connect with me about the writing process. Maybe they are wondering if writing about their experiences might be therapeutic to them, and they’re hoping I will pass off some bit of wisdom that might save them hundreds of wasted hours of time if this writing stuff isn’t therapeutic afterall.
And the other problem with this objection is that writing the book–and specifically publishing the book–actually has made me happier, but not for the reasons that people seem to assume, which I figure are a) writing is “therapeutic” and b) publishing is a glorious experience that brings you uninterrupted joy and the praise of others.
And yes, writing some of the early pages of the book actually was–cringe–therapeutic. The first scribblings of the book started on a notepad I had in my purse that I pulled out waiting in an attorney’s waiting room. Seated across from me was a very thin woman of a certain age with a box of legal papers on her lap that she held tightly with her two thin hands. She had a very spare veneer of hair left which was combed over in an attempt to cover her scalp. Was she going through chemo and divorce? I wondered. And in this juncture of my life when I was frankly totally miserable and self-involved, I had a moment of insight that pulled me out of myself, of seeing that I was a part of something larger than my own private drama.
I took out the notebook and scribbled a short note about this woman. Making that note made me feel connected to the loss of others, making my loss seem smaller, which yes is therapeutic. And I continued pulling out that notebook for the next few months, making notes about the most hideous moments of the freefall through misery called divorce. Eventually, I took the notes to the computer, and yes, beginning to sketch out a story felt better than wallowing. But then, the craft of writing took over, and while it is therapeutic to be involved in any endeavor that requires concentration and focus, writing a memoir is work, and it’s work that’s not as self-serving as it’s made out to be; my desire was to write a story that would capture the larger experience of divorce through my specific personal experience. There’s a heap of revision and research that goes into that, two R words I don’t usually associate with something that is therapeutic per se.
But, as I said, writing the book and the book’s publication has made me happier, and I’ve struggled sometimes to articulate just how that’s happened. Yes, there’s a feeling of success and that’s been good. I’ve made some wonderful friends who I never would have met if I hadn’t written the book. But I’ve always known there was something else, something that I couldn’t quite pinpoint.
I began to crack the code, though, after watching this “The Power of Vulnerability” TED lecture in which Brene Brown explains how our happiness depends on our willingness to make ourselves vulnerable. If you haven't already (the video has been highly shared on Facebook), I urge you to watch the 20 minute video, but in the meantime, here’s what I took away from "The Power of Vulnerability": Even though we might think fame, glory, and praise will be the tickets to happiness, the true source of our happiness in life lies in our connection to other people, but in order to have that connection we must be willing to reveal our authentic selves to others. People who believe they are worthy of connection tend to be willing to take that risk and therefore keep reestablishing their connection to others and therefore tend to be happier. However, many (most?) of us struggle with the worthiness piece (a feeling of shame can be a clue of this) and tend to avoid feeling vulnerable and duck out from opportunities to reveal our authentic selves.
And here's where the two ideas connect: writing and publishing a memoir requires us to reveal and share the authentic self. To write a full-length memoir, you have to share plenty of stuff that you’d just as soon keep out of public view.There are many reasons to avoid this, and many writers are out there avoiding it right now. It’s scary to write about your own experiences and share a hunk of the real you with people you’ve never met (and even worse--with people you have met), but writing and specifically publishing a memoir has brought me an increased connection to others.
Sometimes it’s strangers who write me and tell me the book has helped them and that’s pretty cool. But the truly amazing part is how King Size has connected me to people already in my circle. Not long ago a mother of one of my daughter’s friends pulled me aside with her face lit up. “I read your book!” she said. Part of me want to curl up. It was an awkward moment, knowing this acquaintance has this special knowledge about me that includes, amongst other vulnerable moments, a blow-by-blow account of my post-divorce romance. “I didn’t know if I should be reading it, ” she said, clearly feeling awkward herself. “But it was so good.” But what I saw in her face in that moment wasn’t praise for the book as literature (what I once thought would make me happy) but that she felt closer to me, that she understood me better. And, yes, it’s awkward this vulnerability stuff, this large-scale revealing of my authentic self.
And yes, it has made me happier.
Hosted by Theo Pauline Nestor, Wild Mountain Memoir Retreat(March 15-17, 2013 at Sleeping Lady Mountain Resort in Washington’s Cascade Mountains) will offer an opportunity for established and emerging memoirists to acquire new skills, build a writing community, and renew their vision as writers. Keynote speaker, Cheryl Strayed, author of the #1 New York Times Bestseller Wild, will talk about memoir's "Big Deep Things": how writers make meaning in memoir, excavating the layers within a narrative, and a writer's use of intuition. Candace Walsh, Suzanne Finnamore, Ariel Gore, EJ Levy, and Theo Pauline Nestor will teach ten different classes focusing on the craft of literary memoir writing, the genre’s ethical and logistical challenges, and strategies for overcoming memoir’s most common obstacles.
Deadline, Thursday February 14th for the Cheryl Strayed/VIDA Memoir Scholarship. See details for applying here.
Comment
Comment by Theo Pauline Nestor on February 14, 2013 at 10:11am Pamela: That's a great story about choosing to be authentic--despite "the cost" you feared you pay. I think this waiting to be struck by lightening feeling is a common one, and it's interesting that in these stories, the "apocalypse" doesn't come...in fact, often this move towards authenticity ushers in good stuff.
Comment by Alexandra Caselle on February 14, 2013 at 9:56am
Comment by Pamela Olson on February 14, 2013 at 9:22am What a perceptive and lovely piece. I remember very well the moment when I was writing my memoir and realized (with a little help from a friend) that I was trying to be breezy and cool in my writing, when I'm not like that at all. My friend told me that if I wasn't going to write something that was recognizable as me to a close friend, I was wasting my time.
I had to start all over, and it was terrifying, but I knew he was right. I crossed a barrier and said to myself, "You know what? This is me. People can take it or leave it. If they don't like it, they can read something else and spend time with someone else."
So I wrote a book that actually resembled me, and when it was released, I held my breath waiting for some kind of apocalypse. I felt like hundreds of people (most of whom I knew, among the first buyers) were reading my diary. I flinched in advance of... I don't know what. Something bad.
But nothing bad happened. People just understood me better, knew me better, as who I actually am. Strangely enough, though, none of my relationships actually changed. Who you are, it turns out, cannot be summarized in a book. Only a certain part of your life, and some fraction of who you were then, can possibly fit on 300 tiny pages.
Who you are, it turns out, is simply how you behave day-to-day. So people know more now about what I did and how I felt in my early twenties when I lived in Palestine. And they know a hell of a lot more about Palestine. But without the honesty as the thread holding it together, it would probably not be worth reading.
And even so, the book does not define me. It's just a small but important part of me. If you want to actually get to know me, it takes more than reading a book. (Incidentally, after I crossed that barrier of finally revealing myself and saying people can take it or leave it, that's when my love life started to turn around -- I stopped putting up with toxic people and met a man whom I showed my authentic self to, warts and all. Three years later, we're getting married in June.)
Comment by Theo Pauline Nestor on February 14, 2013 at 8:32am Hi Alexandra,
Dialogue can be tricky for memoir writers because, yes, we're not running around recording conversations, and yet, dialogue is such a compelling part of stories, so how do we provide that? I think first we have to recognize that we're neither journalists nor court reporters. When we write memoir, we are storytellers and our readers expect us to tell a good story, which includes dialogue. Then on a practical level, I suggest that you strive to get down what you do remember of a conversation in the exact quotes and use summarized dialogue (without quotation marks) for the rest. Try to capture the emotional truth of the conversation, knowing that the reader understands that this is a story based on real life---not a court report.
Theo
Comment by Alexandra Caselle on February 13, 2013 at 7:56pm
Louise Gallagher replied to the discussion 'What did you blog about today?' in the group Bloggers: Let's Make It Work!
Shavon Brown-Robinson replied to the discussion 'What did you blog about today?' in the group Bloggers: Let's Make It Work!© 2013 Created by Kamy Wicoff.

You need to be a member of She Writes to add comments!
Join She Writes