Am I still that person?
Contributor

A few weeks ago, my friend and former jogging partner Ellen Sweet sent me this snapshot that she had just discovered while scanning old photographs into her computer. I remembered the picture, and I may even have a copy of it somewhere, but it was something of a shock to see it illuminated on my computer screen. The shot probably dates from the early 1980s when I had first started running along with half of Manhattan. From the beginning Ellen and I challenged ourselves by entering races in Central Park– races for women only, which this image seems to memorialize. (I should say for the record that Ellen, thinner and lighter, always ran faster than I did.)  I think my personal best  was a 10 and one half minute mile. A person could well walk faster than that! Still, we were quite faithful about our practice, running almost every morning, usually around the reservoir in Central Park (before it was cleaned up and named after Jackie Kennedy). I never imagined stopping. Ellen still hasn’t.

Somewhere around the time of the new millennium, knee problems forced me first to have an arthroscopy and then, since the surgery didn’t accomplish much, to stop running altogether. I joined a gym and switched to machines. More recently, bored with the gym, its tv screens and spandex bodies, I’ve mainly been walking. But now my same knee is back causing problems, and I’ve been making the rounds of doctors, x rays, mris, and relearning words like meniscus and patella. Tears, not the kind you shed. When I called the first orthopedist recommended to me, the secretary, after asking for my date of birth, told me that I was too old to see this particular doctor, who specialized in sports medicine. So in case I hadn’t noticed, I have officially entered the stage of geriatric medicine. The senior card for the subway is one thing; being rejected by a doctor for being too old is another.


Here’s what I’ve been wondering, not least as a memoirist. Am I still the person in the picture who jogged around the Central Park reservoir, exchanging profundities with Ellen? Also kvetching. The problem goes well beyond this particular picture―from only, let’s say, 30 years ago. The ache in my left knee suggests a connection, but what about the girl in my new memoir? The girl I supposedly was 50 years ago? I’m committed to recreating the past as faithfully as possible, and I do remember 98% of what I’ve written, especially because I have the letters I wrote home to my parents then. Setting aside whatever I might have lied about in those letters, or, more likely, omitted, do I remember “me”? Oddly, my friend seems “the same.”

It’s easy enough to see the differences―I had dark hair, wore contact lenses not glasses, and was at least ten pounds thinner. For me, though, the challenge as a writer is to find a way back into the feelings of that person: the jogging woman who had just lost her mother, a “never-smoker,” as they say now, to lung cancer, and stopped smoking; and the girl who dreamed of being an ex-pat so that she could smoke her way into Left Bank sophistication, stroll down the streets of the Latin Quarter, and try to look like an existentialist? Do I want to remember that girl, that woman, to reexperience those past emotions, many of which were a lot more painful than my injured knee?


That’s what I’ll be asking myself when I sit down with my “first pages” of my Paris memoir, pages to which I’m not supposed to be making mere “cosmetic changes,” when I’ll choose the version I am strong enough to remember.

Let's be friends

The Women Behind She Writes

519 articles
12 articles

Featured Members (7)

123 articles
392 articles
54 articles
60 articles

Featured Groups (7)

Trending Articles

  • Isabel Ibañez on the Query Letter
  • Alice Hoffman on How Magic and Literature Flourish...
  • An Exclusive Interview with Emma Donoghue
  • Donna Tartt on Process, Voice and Her Future As A...
  • Lisa See on Bringing Hidden Stories to Light
  • Taylor Jenkins Reid on Researching Your Novel

Comments
  • Ellen Ferranti

    Changes are inevitable as we get older...but I do believe we retain some of that "same person" inside...I am a NYC doctor of many years .. basically the same person that I was when I graduated from med school...not the same doctor tho--obviously more experienced and knowledgeable...however, medicine has changed...I am not surprised that the secretary told you the doctor didn't see patients your age...medicine is super-specialized / evidence-based and highly impersonal, at times...I am sorry...you are not old, just older and wiser...btw...I can recommend several Orthopedists!

  • Cheryl J. Fish

    I studied with Nancy K. Miller in graduate school in the late 19990s and she always gets to the heart of women's lives with unflinching honesty and keen powers of observation.

  • Julie Luek

    First, just from this post, I can't wait to read your finished book. I love writing that can crawl inside me and make me think about my own life. As I approach the empty nest and turning 50, I've been giving this kind of topic a lot of thought, including a memoir type book. It's such a journey isn't it?  And it is difficult to sort through the thoughts, look beyond the external images and remember the heart. Best to you in this-- am excited to read more.